Case study and partner interview
Format. Individual prep then a 1-on-1 presentation and discussion with a partner.
Duration. 40 minutes prep, 15-minute presentation, 45 minutes of Q&A
Panel. One partner (or very senior associate).
Assessed on. Mental agility (critical thinking, synthesis), solutions agility (commercial awareness) and communication.
Typical scenarios. A domestic client acquiring an overseas competitor with supply-chain vulnerabilities; a multinational facing an IP dispute alongside cross-border regulatory change; or a company restructuring debt under market pressure.
Common failure modes. Reading too long and failing to structure the presentation, panicking when a new commercial fact is introduced, or giving purely academic legal answers.
Tactical advice. Budget the 40 minutes strictly (roughly 20 reading and annotating, 20 drafting structure), treat the presentation as an executive summary, and signpost clearly, for example three risks: commercial, regulatory, reputational.
Written exercise
Format. Solo analytical writing task on a computer or paper.
Duration. 25 minutes
Panel. Invigilated by Graduate Recruitment, with no active assessors in the room.
Assessed on. Solutions agility (attention to detail, organisation), communication (written clarity and tone) and change agility.
Typical scenarios. Drafting an internal briefing note for a senior associate summarising a newly surfaced risk, or a structured client email explaining next steps after a hitch in negotiations.
Common failure modes. Not finishing due to poor time management, writing in an overly informal style, or failing to proofread.
Tactical advice. Spend the first three minutes outlining the structure, keep paragraphs short with bold headers where helpful, and leave two minutes at the end to proofread, since presentation is heavily weighted.
Scenario-based and competency interview
Format. A highly structured 1-on-1 dialogue.
Duration. 60 minutes
Panel. One HR Graduate Recruitment specialist or a senior associate.
Assessed on. People agility (collaboration, emotional intelligence), change agility (adaptability, resilience) and drive/motivation for corporate law at A&O Shearman.
Typical scenarios. A partner task that conflicts with urgent work promised to an associate, or discovering an error in a document already sent to opposing counsel.
Common failure modes. Generic rehearsed answers, claiming you would never make a mistake, or failing to show a realistic understanding of a trainee's place in the hierarchy.
Tactical advice. Lean on STAR for behavioural questions and walk through your internal logic for situational ones, prioritising transparency, accountability and proactive communication.
Trainee Q&A / social session
Format. An informal group conversation.
Duration. 30 minutes
Panel. Current first or second-year trainees and your cohort.
Assessed on. Explicitly unassessed, though flagrant unprofessionalism or rudeness is flagged to Graduate Recruitment.
Typical scenarios. Casual conversation about work-life balance, seat choices, international secondments or the integration of the legacy firms.
Common failure modes. Treating trainees as competitors to cross-examine, asking engineered formal business questions to show off, or shutting down because the assessment feels over.
Tactical advice. Use the time to gather authentic detail about the trainee experience, asking about day-to-day tasks, how feedback is given and what surprised them most when they joined.